Persona 5 Royal, an enhanced version of the critically acclaimed Persona 5, offers players an expansive and intricate narrative filled with rich character development, engaging gameplay, and moral dilemmas. One of the most compelling characters in this universe is Makoto Niijima. As the vice-president of the student council and a member of the Phantom Thieves, her character embodies a complex blend of duty, morality, and personal growth. This article will explore the intricate layers of Makoto's character, her development throughout the game, and the moral dilemmas she faces, particularly in relation to her role within the Phantom Thieves and her relationship with authority and justice.

The Setting: A World of Shadows and Reality

Persona 5 Royal takes place in modern-day Tokyo, where the protagonist and his friends grapple with societal expectations, personal ambitions, and the darker aspects of human nature. The game’s dual world of reality and the Metaverse serves as a backdrop for intense character development and moral exploration.

The Role of the Metaverse

The Metaverse is a supernatural realm that reflects the inner desires and distorted perceptions of individuals. Within this world, the Phantom Thieves seek to change the hearts of corrupt adults by confronting their Shadows. This unique setting is crucial for understanding Makoto's character arc.

Society and Authority

The game's portrayal of societal structures and authority figures is central to the narrative. Makoto's initial role as a diligent student council member reflects her commitment to upholding these structures, but as the story progresses, her views are challenged, leading to significant character development.

Introducing Makoto Niijima

Makoto Niijima is introduced as a serious and studious character, embodying the archetype of a responsible student. However, her character is far more complex than it initially appears.

Initial Impressions

At first glance, Makoto seems to be a typical model student, focused on her duties and expectations. Her strict adherence to rules makes her a formidable presence in the school, but it also isolates her from her peers.

Hidden Depths

Beneath her composed exterior lies a character filled with ambition, insecurity, and a desire for justice. Her motivations and struggles become more pronounced as players delve deeper into her story.

Joining the Phantom Thieves

The Catalyst for Change

Makoto's decision to join the Phantom Thieves marks a critical turning point in her character development. Initially skeptical of their methods, she soon recognizes the potential for change within herself and society.

The Influence of the Phantom Thieves

The Phantom Thieves challenge Makoto's perceptions of justice and authority. As she becomes involved with them, her character begins to evolve, leading to profound transformations in her beliefs and motivations.

  • Doubt and Conflict: Makoto grapples with her loyalty to the authorities she once respected and the revolutionary spirit of the Phantom Thieves.
  • Personal Growth: Through her experiences, Makoto learns to embrace her own sense of justice, moving beyond rigid adherence to rules.

The Moral Dilemma of Justice

Defining Justice

One of the central themes in Persona 5 Royal is the exploration of justice. Makoto's character is deeply intertwined with this theme, as she must navigate her understanding of right and wrong.

Authority vs. Rebellion

Makoto's initial alignment with authority figures creates a moral conflict. As she witnesses the corruption and injustice perpetrated by those in power, her views begin to shift, leading to an internal struggle between her ingrained beliefs and the new realities she faces.

  • Influence of Experiences: Encounters with corrupt individuals and the consequences of their actions force Makoto to confront her ideals.
  • Questioning Authority: Her journey involves questioning the legitimacy of the authority she once upheld, reflecting the broader societal critique embedded in the game.

The Role of Relationships

Bonds with the Phantom Thieves

Makoto's relationships with her fellow Phantom Thieves play a crucial role in her development. These connections provide her with support, challenge her perspectives, and enable her growth.

Key Relationships

  • Ren Amamiya (Joker): As the leader of the Phantom Thieves, Ren serves as a source of inspiration for Makoto. His moral compass and determination challenge her to rethink her own values.
  • Ann Takamaki: Ann's free-spirited nature contrasts with Makoto's disciplined approach, encouraging her to embrace spontaneity and question societal norms.

The Transformation of Makoto Niijima

From Rule-Follower to Revolutionary

As the story progresses, Makoto's transformation from a rule-following student to a passionate revolutionary becomes evident. This shift is marked by significant character development that resonates with players.

Embracing Her Own Justice

By the end of the game, Makoto fully embraces her identity as a Phantom Thief and a catalyst for change. She learns to trust her instincts and challenge authority when it conflicts with her sense of justice.

  • Personal Agency: Makoto's journey is about reclaiming her agency and defining her own path, separate from societal expectations.
  • Empowerment: Her transformation symbolizes the empowerment of individuals to stand against oppressive systems, a central theme in Persona 5 Royal.

The Challenges of Leadership

Navigating Group Dynamics

As a member of the Phantom Thieves, Makoto faces the challenges of leadership and teamwork. Balancing her ambitions with the needs of the group creates tension and opportunities for growth.

Conflict Resolution

Makoto often finds herself mediating conflicts within the group, showcasing her natural leadership abilities. These moments highlight her emotional intelligence and commitment to the team's goals.

  • Building Trust: As she navigates these dynamics, Makoto learns to build trust and foster collaboration, essential traits for effective leadership.
  • Self-Reflection: The challenges she faces prompt Makoto to reflect on her motivations and the importance of teamwork in achieving their shared goals.

The Climax of Makoto's Arc

Confronting the Final Boss

The culmination of Makoto's character arc occurs during the climactic battle against the final boss. This confrontation serves as a test of her growth and the values she has embraced.

Embracing Her Identity

In this moment, Makoto fully embraces her identity as a Phantom Thief, showcasing her evolution from a hesitant follower to a proactive leader. Her actions reflect her newfound understanding of justice and her commitment to fighting for what is right.

  • Symbolic Victory: The battle serves not only as a physical confrontation but also as a symbolic victory for Makoto, representing her triumph over her past insecurities and doubts.
  • Character Resolution: This climax solidifies her character's resolution, allowing players to witness the culmination of her journey.


Makoto Niijima's character arc in Persona 5 Royal exemplifies the complexities of morality, justice, and personal growth. Her transformation from a dutiful student to a passionate member of the Phantom Thieves illustrates the game's exploration of authority and rebellion. As players navigate Makoto's journey, they are invited to reflect on their own beliefs and the nature of justice in a flawed society. Through her relationships, moral dilemmas, and commitment to change, Makoto emerges as a compelling and relatable character, embodying the spirit of resistance that defines Persona 5 Royal.